9 Things Guys Secretly Find Attractive About a Plain “Girl Next Door”

8. She has an adorably embarrassed way of smiling.


“Looking at that adorably shy expression makes my heart race.” A plain girl might not always seem as expressive, but the little shy smiles she shows from time to time can make a man swoon. If a guy feels like a girl smiles only for him, it can be really hard for him to let her go.