Home How To Instantly Be Left Off His List Of "Potential Girlfriends" After Meeting Him For The First Time 8 ways to make a bad first impression on a man 2. Being overly cautious with men “I had no ulterior motives, but she snapped at me like, ‘Stop staring at me!’ That ticked me off.” Being overly cautious can create an ugly situation, which only results in disappointment for both of you. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8